Sunday, April 19, 2009

tax cuts in stimulus...


Tax Cuts, Household Balance Sheets, and the Duration of Recessions

Initially, I opposed tax cuts that would mostly be saved rather than spent because it wouldn't stimulate aggregate demand, and that's what the economy needed. But I've changed my mind about that, and I think tax cuts can be an important part of the solution in a recession like this one.

Here's why. This recession has wiped out a lot of balance sheets in the financial sector, and it has also done severe damage to the balance sheets of individuals, especially those with a large proportion of their savings in financial assets or real estate (equity in their homes). Those households are not going to spend until those savings for retirement and other purposes are replenished, so how soon the end of the recession comes depends, in part, on how fast those balance sheets are repaired. Tax cuts help to do this, some types better than others. The effect of these balance sheet repairing tax cuts may not be immediately obvious since they are going toward saving, but it helps the recession end earlier than otherwise. Big ticket items, in particular, are less likely to be purchased so long as balance sheets still have big, missing pieces.

So tax cuts should be part of a recovery package, and they can be used in two ways. Some tax cuts can be used to stimulate the economy immediately by helping families who are having trouble and cannot save even if they want to, they have no choice but to consume it all, and part can be targeted at speeding up the recovery by helping households make up for losses. We have to understand, though, that this component of the package will not stimulate aggregate demand immediately, the main effect is to bring an end to the recession sooner, and other measures - increase government spending or additional tax cuts targeted at people who will spend it all - must be increased to compensate.

Recessions can be characterized by their depth and their duration, and my initial opposition to tax cuts underplayed, I think, the role they can play in reducing the duration. I still think the best and most certain way to stimulate aggregate demand is through government spending, and that government spending can itself help to end a recession sooner, but there's a role for tax cuts too. Not in every recession, at least not to the same extent, it's not always the case that a recession wipes out household balance sheets like this one did. But when that happens, household balance sheets are one of the things that must be repaired before we can fully recover.

I think Obama put way too much of the stimulus in tax cuts...  they did it to win over Republicans (all 3 of them)

Posted via web from jimnichols's posterous

No comments:

Post a Comment